In a dramatic twist that has reshaped the game, Matthew, the previously overlooked contestant on BBC's The Traitors, may have just orchestrated his own downfall. The 35-year-old creative director, who had faded into the background for much of the series, made a bold and risky play during the episode aired on January 9, 2026.
From Anonymous to Audacious
Until this pivotal episode, Matthew was best known for being one of the show's more anonymous figures, a 'miscellaneous white bloke' who prompted viewers to ask 'Who is Matthew?' on social media. With limited screen time and a perpetually bored expression at the roundtable, he seemed destined to be a Forgettable Faithful.
However, sensing his inconsequential role, Matthew seized a unique opportunity presented by a mission. The victorious trio of Harriet, Matthew, and Traitor Rachel won a prize far greater than immunity: a chance to communicate directly with the Traitors. While secret barrister Harriet was expected to apply pressure, it was Matthew who stunned viewers by attempting a Faustian bargain.
A Fateful Proposal in the Chapel
In the chapel confessional, Matthew made a direct appeal to the Traitors. His suggestion was stark: they should murder the popular fan favourite, Jessie. This move immediately demonstrated a cunning and mettle previously unseen, especially when contrasted with Traitor Stephen's emotional display during Fiona's banishment.
Yet, this power play has left Matthew incredibly vulnerable. By openly coveting the green cloak and trying to insert himself into the Traitors' inner circle, he has painted a target on his back. Crucially, he chose the worst possible moment. Traitor Rachel, having just survived a confrontation with the banished Fiona, will be looking for a new pawn. A recruit she feels no allegiance towards—like Matthew—would be a perfect scapegoat.
The Inevitable Consequences
Matthew has now boxed himself into a corner. Having secured a private audience with the villains, he will return to the Faithful with nothing concrete to report, unless he reveals his own suggested plan for Jessie. In the paranoid environment of The Traitors, where players are banished for mere 'vibes' or pre-existing acquaintances, returning empty-handed from such a summit is a death sentence.
His attempt to transform from a background player into a key schemer is likely to be a dazzling, unforced error. Instead of maintaining a low profile and potentially winning from the middle of the pack, Matthew has thrust himself into the crossfire. Whether the Traitors accept or decline his offer, the ripples from his chapel summit will almost certainly see him thrown to the Faithful at a future roundtable.
The Traitors, Stephen and Rachel, will make their decision known in the next episode, airing on January 14 at 8pm on BBC One and iPlayer. But the damage is likely already done. Matthew will probably soon long for the gentle anonymity of being the bloke nobody could remember.
