Christian Pulisic has been training away from his teammates in recent days, raising doubts about his availability for the United States' second World Cup group match against Australia. The US star was on a 'modified' training schedule for the third consecutive day after being substituted at halftime in the 4-1 opening win over Paraguay.
Pochettino's dilemma
Mauricio Pochettino now faces the practical test of the new 48-team World Cup format. The Argentinian coach wisely played it safe by pulling Pulisic before his calf could suffer further damage. The attacking midfielder expressed optimism about his fitness, but as of Wednesday, he was still training separately and wearing a sleeve on his left calf.
Pochettino must weigh how much to gamble with player fitness after securing three points, which may be enough to advance. However, the US could face tough challenges against an Australian team irritated by disparaging comments in US media, with control of Group D at stake.
Option 1: Gio Reyna - the man in form
Gio Reyna last played 60 minutes for club or country on December 19, 2025, but his incredible late goal against Paraguay makes him a strong candidate. Despite struggling at club level, Reyna's technical acumen and incisive passing could help against Australia's organized defense. He came off the bench against Paraguay and could start if Pulisic is unavailable.
Option 2: Brenden Aaronson - tireless workhorse
Pochettino could unleash Reyna after Australia is tired out by Brenden Aaronson. The 25-year-old brings tireless off-ball movement and pressing, making the team better through thankless efforts. However, Aaronson has not been a regular part of Pochettino's plans, logging only 11 minutes in March camp. He could open space for Folarin Balogun and others while wearing down Australia's defense.
Option 3: Tim Weah - width and shot volume
With opponents focusing on Balogun, Pulisic has thrived in space. Neither Reyna nor Aaronson can replicate his goal threat. Tim Weah, a versatile option who can play on the right flank or as a center-forward, could return to the lineup. Weah scored at the last World Cup against Wales and adds another capable shooter. This may require Weston McKennie to shift left.
Option 4: Midfield reshuffle
Pulisic's absence could push McKennie forward, while Malik Tillman or Sebastian Berhalter steps into midfield. Tillman impressed against Paraguay with progressive passes and an assist. Berhalter is the set-piece specialist. Cristian Roldan also provided assists against Australia previously. A midfield of Tillman, McKennie, and Tyler Adams could provide steel in a hard-fought game.
