Helen Haines, a key architect of the National Anti-Corruption Commission (Nacc), has urged the Albanese government to use the upcoming vacancy for deputy commissioner to restore public confidence in the watchdog. Haines, who helped craft the legislation establishing the Nacc and sits on its parliamentary oversight committee, emphasized the need for a clear and transparent appointment process.
Deputy Commissioner Resignation
Deputy Commissioner Nicole Rose announced her resignation this month and will relocate overseas. She is set to finish her role this month before taking a period of leave. Haines stated that the replacement process must be thorough to allow the joint committee on the Nacc to effectively review and approve appointments.
Call for Merit-Based Selection
Haines stressed that replacing Rose is a critical opportunity for the government to strengthen public confidence in the Nacc. She advocated for a merit-based and independent selection process, noting that Australians should understand the required skills, experience, and how conflicts of interest will be declared. In the longer term, she suggested legislating such a process for all senior Nacc appointments.
Background of Controversy
A statutory review of the Nacc's early operations is expected in 2027, following a controversial first five years. Criticism has centered on Commissioner Paul Brereton's external work for the Defence department and the Nacc's handling of referrals related to the illegal robodebt scheme. An October 2024 report by Nacc inspector Gail Furness found that Brereton was affected by apprehended bias in decision-making processes, though no intentional wrongdoing was found. Brereton has also completed consulting work for the inspector general of the Australian defence force while serving as commissioner.
Current Operations
The Nacc's latest update indicates it is conducting 29 preliminary investigations and 36 corruption investigations. Four matters are currently before the courts, and 11 convictions have been secured to date.
Haines concluded that the appointment process should be beyond reproach and as transparent as the public expects of the Nacc itself. She warned that the clock is ticking, with Rose taking leave from late May and no acting appointment announced yet.
