The latest series of BBC One's hit reality show The Traitors has ignited a fierce debate among its massive fanbase, following the introduction of a game-altering secret twist. The show's second episode, which aired on January 2, 2026, demonstrated how the bold decision to plant an undisclosed 'Traitor' among the contestants has radically transformed the dynamics of the iconic roundtable.
A Roundtable Revelation
The fourth series, which premiered on New Year's Day with a new cast of 22, is already breaking records. The debut episode attracted an average overnight audience of 6.4 million viewers, making it the most-watched opening episode in the show's history. Episode two wasted no time, with contestant Netty becoming the first murder victim at the hands of the chosen Traitors: barrister Hugo, communications head Rachel, and cyber security consultant Stephen.
This led to immediate suspicion falling on Ross, whose emotional reunion with an old acquaintance outside the castle gates raised eyebrows. However, the roundtable discussion quickly became a battleground of accusations. Despite the efforts of her secret daughter, fellow contestant Roxy, to deflect attention, Judy, a Doncaster child liaison officer, found herself in the firing line due to a campaign led by contestant Sam.
The tension culminated in Judy being almost unanimously voted out. Yet, for the first time, the climactic moment where the banished contestant reveals their true role was fraught with uncertainty for everyone—players and viewers alike—thanks to the secret 'red cloak' Traitor whose identity is unknown to all.
Viewers Divided Over 'Top Tier' Twist
The new format twist has provoked a strong and divided reaction from the audience at home. Many took to social media to praise the fresh layer of suspense. One viewer declared the secret traitor role 'top tier', admitting it created genuine tension even for those watching. Another fan, Ez Smith, celebrated the shared experience, stating: 'Isn’t it great that we, the public, can react to finding out if the banished player is a faithful or a traitor!'
However, not all feedback was positive. Viewer Stewart King expressed scepticism on X, theorising: 'Not enjoying this secret traitor twist. It really makes the role of the actual chosen traitors completely redundant.' Others, like fan Jim Fraser, relished the chaos it caused, replying: 'I love how furious this has made the traitors!'
Clues and Consequences
The episode ended with the secret Traitor nominating retiree Ben, sweet shop worker Reece, and civil servant Maz for potential banishment. This move led the official Traitors to theorise that the secret ally is likely a woman. This hunch was supported by former contestant Maddy Smedley, who advised on strategy via social media.
Fans are already speculating how long the twist can last, with many predicting the murder shortlist mechanism will be key to unmasking the red cloak, as their name will not appear on the list. Meanwhile, Roxy vowed to continue in the game with renewed determination following her mother Judy's early exit, criticising the 'herd mentality' of the roundtable.
With the prize pot standing at £120,000 and the stakes higher than ever, The Traitors continues nightly on BBC One at 8pm, promising more deception, drama, and divisive twists as the hunt continues.
