The BBC has axed 'I Kissed a Girl' after its second series, along with its male counterpart 'I Kissed a Boy', citing funding challenges. This decision marks the end of the UK's first dating shows with exclusively gay casts, a format that has been both groundbreaking and hugely popular among queer audiences.
A bittersweet farewell to a groundbreaking show
Announced in March, the cancellation of both shows has sparked disappointment among fans and critics alike. The BBC stated that "difficult choices in light of our funding challenges" led to the decision. The shows were not only unprecedented but also provided a platform for vital queer conversations rarely seen on mainstream television.
Despite the cancellation, the second series of 'I Kissed a Girl' is described as "ridiculously fun" yet bittersweet. Hosted by Dannii Minogue in the style of Maya Jama from 'Love Island', and compered by TikToker Charley Marlowe, the show is filled with queer culture references, from Jane McDonald to Mighty Hoopla. While some references may feel cynical, they are unique to this format.
A cast full of charm and diversity
The cast of women is praised as wonderful, including Faye, a self-described "chaotic" and "feral" femme who wants someone obsessed with her; Renee, bold and rowdy with a soft center; and Ebony, a Geordie delivery driver with a cheeky glint. The show avoids a queer utopia, featuring red flags and immature behavior, but overall feels more wholesome than other dating shows. Separate beds are appreciated, though contestants rarely stay in their own.
According to the review, the show excels in fostering important conversations. Elisha, a femme-for-femme lesbian, discusses the exhaustion of proving her sexuality. Renee talks about being a masculine lesbian who feels she isn't treated as the emotional woman she is. One participant is frank about her period of celibacy and desire for a partner with similar intimacy views. These discussions serve as a resource for queer women watching at home.
Fun and important, but cancelled too soon
The three episodes released for review fizz with excitement, featuring Sapphic pop stars like the Japanese House and Nimmo. The reviewer awards four stars but notes the show feels important enough for five, given its value to younger viewers. The Apprentice has run for 20 series, Dragons' Den for 23, while the first gay UK dating franchise managed only four. 'I Kissed a Girl' airs on BBC Three and is available on iPlayer in the UK and Binge in Australia.
