Former Germany international Didi Hamann has sparked transfer speculation after comparing Napoli's Scott McTominay to Arsenal star Declan Rice and suggesting the Scottish midfielder could make a dramatic return to the Premier League.
From Manchester United Outcast to Napoli Hero
Since his £25.7 million move from Manchester United in August 2024, McTominay has transformed his career in Italy. The 28-year-old midfielder played a pivotal role in Napoli's Serie A title triumph last season, quickly establishing himself as a fan favourite and club icon.
His statistics demonstrate remarkable improvement: 12 goals and six assists in 34 Serie A matches during the 2024-25 campaign earned him the Most Valuable Player award in Italian football. His performances were so impressive that he received a Ballon d'Or nomination, finishing 18th overall in the 2025 rankings - nine places above Arsenal's Declan Rice.
The Declan Rice Comparison
Hamann sees clear parallels between the two midfielders, despite their different career trajectories. 'I think he's pretty similar to Declan Rice,' Hamann told CoinCasino. 'He likes to roam around, Declan Rice. He used to be a holding midfielder, now he's really everywhere.'
Both players have evolved from defensive-minded midfielders into complete box-to-box operators. While Rice typically occupies deeper positions for Arsenal, McTominay thrives higher up the pitch for Napoli, making powerful runs and contributing significantly to attacks.
The comparison becomes particularly interesting when examining their goal output. Both players have scored 18 goals for their current clubs, but McTominay achieved this in just 52 appearances compared to Rice's 121 games.
Transfer Speculation and Reality
Hamann believes McTominay's sensational form will attract Premier League interest. 'I can see Scott McTominay back in the Premier League,' he stated, noting that the Scottish international 'probably didn't get the credit' during his time at Manchester United.
However, transfer expert Fabrizio Romano has dismissed January move rumours as 'fantasy'. McTominay remains under contract with Napoli until 2028, and the club reportedly has no desire to sell their star player, who is understood to be very happy in Italy.
The situation has led to criticism of Manchester United's decision to sell McTominay, with club legends including Peter Schmeichel and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer questioning the £25.7 million transfer. Gary Lineker has suggested McTominay would have been 'perfect' for current United manager Ruben Amorim's system.
McTominay continues to impress this season with three Champions League goals in five games and two goals plus two assists in 11 Serie A appearances, ensuring the transfer speculation is likely to continue despite Napoli's determination to keep him.
