Michael Carrick has earned the right to bring equilibrium to Manchester United. It would be foolish of the club to undo a winning, entertaining formula by turning elsewhere for a permanent head coach.
Carrick's Success as Interim Manager
Under Carrick, Manchester United have secured 33 points from 15 games, topping the form table. They have beaten rivals, guaranteed Champions League qualification, and are likely to finish third. Despite this, there is still hesitation about appointing him permanently.
Comparisons to Solskjær
Some skeptics point to the Ole Gunnar Solskjær experience as a cautionary tale. However, Carrick's situation is different. He inherited a less demoralized squad and quickly implemented fresh ideas, effecting real change.
Why Carrick is the Right Choice
Julian Nagelsmann, while talented, would not be available until after the World Cup and would require another style change. Cesc Fàbregas and Xabi Alonso are also risks, and Andoni Iraola's chaotic style may not scale. Carrick, on the other hand, has proven his ability to manage pressure and earn player loyalty.
Building a Balanced Squad
United now have a functioning structure, and a failed appointment is no longer disastrous. Carrick has created a balanced squad that can fit various playing styles. He has not panicked during difficult periods, keeping ideas simple and empowering his players.
Tactical Flexibility
Carrick has devised different strategies for different games, making United unpredictable without deviating from core principles. The team attacks with intensity and directness, scoring various goals and risking defeat to win.
Future Plans
Carrick envisions a side that controls possession with tempo and aggression, using quick passes and movement to navigate tight spaces. The focus is on midfield, and it makes sense to let Carrick replace himself as a player.
Ultimately, rejecting a head coach who has won and entertained, after 13 years of struggle, would be foolish. Carrick has earned the chance to continue his work.
