The Duchess of Sussex has returned to screens with a seasonal edition of her lifestyle series, and the reception appears to have undergone a festive transformation. Meghan Markle's "With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration" has arrived on Netflix, prompting a notable shift in tone from its earlier critiques.
A Seasonal Shift in Perception
Previous instalments of With Love, Meghan faced widespread derision from both professional reviewers and the public. Memorable moments, like the infamous pretzel re-bagging incident, were held up as examples of the show's perceived excess. However, the context of a Christmas special has, according to commentator Polly Hudson, made the Duchess's signature style finally "make sense".
The special retains the hallmarks of the series: what Hudson describes as "psychobabble word salads" and "extreme hosting". Yet, framed by yuletide festivities, these elements are re-evaluated. The show's over-the-top nature is now seen as aligning with the traditional extravagance of the season itself.
The Eccentric Aunt of Christmas TV
Hudson suggests Meghan now occupies the role of the familiar, if quirky, family member at a Christmas gathering. Her pronouncements—from "I love spinach!" to "A tradition has to have a beginning"—are viewed as part of her character. The reviewer notes the Duchess appears genuinely happy and relaxed, a notable feat given the intense scrutiny her every move and expression receives.
The production value and aesthetic of the special are highlighted as undeniable strengths. From artfully tied aprons and origami-level gift wrapping to stunning handmade wreaths and meticulously arranged crudité platters, nothing is average. "The walk she's walking genuinely looks shop-bought," Hudson observes, acknowledging the flawless execution.
Comfort in Consistency and a Festive Verdict
There is a noted comfort in Meghan's refusal to alter her approach despite global mockery. In an uncertain world, her consistent persona becomes something predictable. The review ultimately concludes that while the show is "cringingly ultra-extra" and full of "nonsense", that is precisely what Christmas entertainment often entails.
Hudson posits that even the most ardent "hate-watcher" might be won over by the seasonal cheer, sparking a longing for handmade crackers with personalised gifts. The piece ends with a reminder that viewing is optional, but for those who choose to watch, envy of the picture-perfect celebration is a natural response—and one shared by parents everywhere when their holiday efforts go unappreciated by their children.
