Ancient Oak Tree Felled at Toby Carvery Site Deemed Healthy by Experts
In a controversial incident in north London, a centuries-old oak tree adjacent to a Toby Carvery restaurant was felled last year, with recent expert analysis revealing the tree was in good health and presented no safety risks. The tree, located in Whitewebbs Park, Enfield, and estimated to be between 450 and 500 years old, was removed in April 2025 after the property owner, Mitchells & Butlers, received advice indicating it was dying and posed a threat to public safety.
Forestry Commission Findings Contradict Initial Claims
However, a subsequent investigation by the Forestry Commission has found minimal evidence to justify the tree's removal. A survey conducted prior to the felling described the oak as a 'fine specimen,' and aerial photographs confirmed that none of its branches extended over the nearby car park. Inspectors noted the tree displayed no signs of major diseases, with its trunk largely intact and a cavity suggesting it served as a habitat for wildlife.
Mitchells & Butlers, which leases the land from Enfield Council, initially stated they were informed the tree posed a serious health and safety risk before authorizing the work. The tree has since been reduced to a stump, igniting fury among local residents and environmental campaigners, who have compared the event to the infamous felling of the Sycamore Gap tree at Hadrian's Wall.
Outrage and Calls for Investigation
Dr. Ed Pyne, a senior conservation adviser at the Woodland Trust, expressed grave concerns about the tree's survival prospects, estimating them at less than one percent. He told BBC News, 'I visited the tree in the aftermath and there was absolutely no doubt in my mind the tree was very much alive.' Campaigners, including Ed Allnutt from the Guardians of Whitewebbs group, have demanded a full investigation and enhanced protection for other significant trees in the area, emphasizing that such ancient oaks are invaluable and can support thousands of species.
Tim Leaver, deputy leader of Enfield Council, labeled the tree 'irreplaceable' and called for an apology from the company, noting the felling occurred without the council's knowledge or consent, in clear violation of the site's lease agreement. In response, Toby Carvery's chief executive, Phil Urban, asserted the company 'acted in good faith' and apologized for the distress caused, acknowledging the emotional impact of losing such a historic tree.
Ongoing Legal and Community Fallout
The controversy has led to further action, with Enfield Council reportedly serving an eviction notice to the restaurant in October 2025. As the community grapples with the loss, this incident underscores broader issues of environmental stewardship and the protection of heritage trees in urban settings, prompting calls for stricter regulations and accountability in similar cases across London.
