Andris Nelsons' Mendelssohn Box Set Showcases Prodigious Talent
Andris Nelsons' tenure with the Boston Symphony Orchestra may have ended prematurely, but a new box set with the Gewandhaus Orchestra serves as compelling evidence of the Latvian conductor's exceptional abilities. This collection, titled Mendelssohn: Symphonies and Oratorios, released by Deutsche Grammophon, highlights Nelsons' dynamic approach to the composer's works, recorded live between 2021 and 2024.
Dynamic Performances with Historical Significance
The Gewandhaus Orchestra has a deep connection to Mendelssohn, as the composer led the ensemble in Leipzig from 1835 until his death in 1847. Nelsons capitalizes on this heritage, delivering performances that are brisk yet never rushed, with phrasing that is elastic and full of dynamic light and shade. The five symphonies, in particular, stand out as special interpretations.
For instance, the opening movement of the Italian Symphony is ultra-lithe, while the woodwind filigree in the Scottish Symphony's scherzo sparkles with precision. Under Nelsons' direction, the often-overlooked First Symphony takes its rightful place alongside its more colorful counterparts, demonstrating his skill in bringing out the nuances of each piece.
Inclusion of Oratorios with Distinguished Soloists
The seven-disc set also features two oratorios, Elias (Elijah) and Paulus (St Paul), both sung in German rather than the Victorian English translations familiar in some countries. Elias boasts a distinguished lineup of soloists, including Golda Schultz, Werner Güra, and Wiebke Lehmkuhl. Andrè Schuen delivers a compelling performance in the title role, with a Lieder singer's instinct for text that rivals Fischer-Dieskau's interpretations.
The MDR Radio Choir, while somewhat polite in the Baal choruses, produces a tremendous noise, especially from the male singers. Paulus marks Deutsche Grammophon's first recording of this work, with Nelsons expertly ferreting out the drama in what is often considered Elias's diffident relative. Georg Zeppenfeld brings a grumbly intensity to the pugnacious apostle, complemented by Julia Kleiter's radiant soprano solos.
Why Nelsons' Departure Raises Questions
This box set raises an intriguing question: why has one of the world's great conductors been shown the door in Boston? The performances here underscore Nelsons' prodigious talent and his ability to breathe new life into classical repertoire. With its blend of historical significance and modern dynamism, this collection is a must-listen for classical music enthusiasts, showcasing Nelsons at the height of his powers with an orchestra steeped in Mendelssohn's legacy.
