Is This Thing On? Review: A Comedy-Drama of Catharsis and Connection
In Is This Thing On?, Bradley Cooper directs a poignant and spirited tale that explores the unexpected intersections of personal crisis and creative expression. The film, which draws inspiration from a real-life anecdote by British comedian John Bishop, follows Alex, played with gentle sensitivity by Will Arnett, as he stumbles into the world of standup comedy amidst the painful unravelling of his marriage.
A Departure from Type for Will Arnett
Will Arnett, best known for his outrageously comedic roles in television series like Arrested Development and the animated hit BoJack Horseman, takes on a more nuanced dramatic part here. He portrays Alex, a regular man with a conventional job in finance, who finds himself on the brink of divorce. The character's journey begins with a weed-fuelled whim at an open mic night, where his unfunny yet sweetly honest confessional ramblings unexpectedly resonate with audiences.
Arnett brings a wounded, sympathetic quality to the role, his handsome face conveying a depth of emotion that makes Alex's loneliness palpable. This performance marks a significant shift from his usual fare, showcasing his versatility as an actor committed to exploring the quieter, more reflective aspects of human experience.
The Unconvincing Heart of the Narrative
Where the film struggles is in its central premise. The story questions whether Alex's foray into comedy is a genuine talent or merely a cathartic episode. His wife Tess, portrayed by the ever-capable Laura Dern, is a former volleyball coach who gave up her thriving career to raise their two children, conceived via IVF. Her growing discontent and Alex's lack of support create a slow, agonising implosion of their marriage.
As Alex begins performing regular gigs in secret, even mining their grisly sex life for material, the film introduces a compelling dynamic. However, it never fully convinces viewers that standup comedy is Alex's true calling, rather than just a temporary escape. The comparison to Tess's clear vocation for sports coaching highlights this narrative ambiguity, leaving audiences to wonder about the authenticity of his commitment.
Supporting Characters and Directorial Choices
Bradley Cooper not only directs but also co-writes and appears in the film, casting himself in a classic Arnett-type role as Balls, an annoying and conceited unemployed actor. This meta-casting adds an interesting layer, though the character's purpose sometimes feels underdeveloped. The supporting cast includes real-life married couple Sean Hayes and Scott Icenogle as friends Stephen and Geoffrey, alongside Andra Day as the sharp-tongued Christine, whose own marital difficulties mirror those of the central couple.
These characters collectively underscore Alex's isolation, none able to truly help him as he feels increasingly unheard. The film effectively captures the loneliness of someone who, like a standup comic doubting their microphone, fears their voice is not reaching anyone.
Strengths and Shortcomings
Is This Thing On? is at its best in the moments between Arnett and Dern, whose chemistry and sympathetic performances make even the less believable elements work in the moment. The film's exploration of how comedy can both heal and harm relationships is thoughtful, if not fully realised. One might wish for a narrative where Alex, inspired by comedy, either renews his marriage or cynically exploits its breakdown for material, but the script opts for a more ambiguous path.
Ultimately, this is a likable and well-acted drama that offers a refreshing take on comedians without delving into darkness or malice. Yet, it leaves viewers yearning for a story that, like John Bishop's own experience, truly flowers into genuine humour. The film releases in the UK on 30 January, following its US debut, with an Australian release set for 5 February.
