BBC Faces Political Impartiality Crisis
The Broadcasting, Entertainment, Communications and Theatre Union (BECTU), the largest union representing BBC staff, has formally demanded the removal of Sir Robbie Gibb from the corporation's board. This dramatic move comes amid growing concerns about the BBC's ability to maintain political independence and resist external pressure.
Union Takes Stand Against Political Influence
In a strongly worded letter sent on Friday 14th November 2025 to Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy and BBC board chair Samir Shah, BECTU expressed deep concerns about the organisation's journalistic integrity. The union stated that its members are worried about the BBC's capacity to resist political pressure and uphold the integrity of its journalism.
The demand for Sir Robbie Gibb's removal follows the high-profile resignations of BBC director-general Tim Davie and chief executive Deborah Turness. These departures were linked to ongoing impartiality controversies, including the editing of US President Donald Trump's speech in a Panorama episode last year.
Background of Controversial Board Member
Sir Robbie Gibb's appointment has faced significant opposition due to his close ties with the Conservative party. He previously served as Theresa May's director of communications after building his career within the BBC. The Guardian reported that sources claimed Sir Robbie had led the charge against Mr Davie, helping to force his resignation through what some described as a coup.
However, a friend of Sir Robbie's dismissed this theory as absolute nonsense when speaking to Deadline. Despite these denials, BECTU remains firm in its position, stating that staff cannot have faith in BBC leadership while someone perceived as sympathetic to campaigns undermining the corporation holds a crucial board position.
Government Response and Ongoing Fallout
Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has been actively involved in the situation, revealing she has been speaking daily and frequently with BBC senior staff about the fallout from the Trump speech editing controversy. She asserted that the broadcaster has consulted lawyers and is confident about being protected against defamation claims.
The crisis reached a new level when BBC chair Samir Shah personally wrote to Donald Trump to apologise for how his speech was edited. In a message to staff, Mr Shah acknowledged this has been a difficult week for the corporation, with employees experiencing sadness, anger and frustration.
Mr Shah strongly refuted suggestions of institutional bias at the BBC and expressed fierce pride in the organisation's world-class journalism. He confirmed that work has already begun to address staff concerns while praising employees for their resilience during this challenging period.
The union maintains that both the government and BBC board must demonstrate genuine commitment to the organisation's future, mission, independence and values. BECTU believes that removing Sir Robbie Gibb from his board position is essential to restoring confidence in the BBC's political impartiality.
