Manchester United's interim manager Michael Carrick has been strongly advised to consider selling the club's £36.5 million signing Joshua Zirkzee before the January transfer window concludes. The deadline for winter deals is set for 7pm on Monday night, giving the Red Devils a final opportunity to make last-minute adjustments to their squad.
Pressure Mounts on Zirkzee's Future
Zirkzee, who joined United from Bologna in 2024 for a substantial fee, has largely struggled to make an impact at Old Trafford. The Netherlands international managed just three Premier League goals during his debut season and has started only four matches in the current campaign. His inconsistent performances have led to growing speculation about his long-term future at the club.
Former Striker Advocates for Sale
Ex-Manchester United forward Louis Saha has publicly suggested that the club should cash in on Zirkzee. Speaking to Gambling.com, Saha expressed doubts about the player's suitability for United's requirements. "I think yes," Saha responded when asked if United made a mistake signing Zirkzee and should now sell him. "I will have less concern about him leaving because he's not playing regularly, he's not the first choice. If we need a main striker, it's almost not his type."
Saha further questioned whether Zirkzee remains the same player who impressed in Italy, noting "where's the player we saw in Italy? I doubt that he's the same type of player that we're looking for in the future." However, he did acknowledge Zirkzee's technical abilities and potential to adapt, while emphasising the need for the striker to focus on immediate contributions rather than future plans.
Carrick's Squad Management Challenges
Amid these transfer discussions, Carrick faces the delicate task of managing his squad while aiming for a strong finish to the season. The former United midfielder has already reintegrated young talent Kobbie Mainoo into the first-team setup, dismissing any suggestions that the 20-year-old could be moved on during this window.
United's transfer strategy appears focused on future planning, with the club tracking several midfield targets including Nottingham Forest's Elliot Anderson, Crystal Palace's Adam Wharton, and Brighton's Carlos Baleba. The Red Devils are expected to pursue significant midfield reinforcements in the summer, particularly following Casemiro's announcement that he will leave the club at season's end.
Zirkzee's Changing Stance
Earlier in January, reports suggested Zirkzee was open to a winter move to boost his fading hopes of selection for this summer's World Cup. However, more recent indications suggest the striker is now determined to remain at United and fight for his place in the team.
When questioned about Zirkzee's future during his Friday press conference, Carrick offered a measured response. "I think Josh has just been trying to work to get fit and get back around the group and it's been great to have him back training yesterday with a group for the first time," Carrick stated. "That's literally as far as it goes for me and for Josh. I'm looking forward to working with him. That's it. Nothing else needs to be said."
Broader Transfer Context
The Zirkzee situation unfolds against a backdrop of United's broader transfer considerations. While the club desires a new central midfielder, they appear prepared to wait until summer for major investment in that area. This strategic patience reflects both financial considerations and Carrick's cautious approach to squad disruption during the crucial final months of the season.
As the transfer deadline approaches, all eyes remain on Old Trafford to see whether Carrick will heed the advice to offload Zirkzee or retain the Dutch striker as part of his plans for United's push towards potential permanent management of the club.
