Readers have rallied behind Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett's proposal to scrap fines for parents who take children on holiday during term time, arguing that such penalties are unfair and that family experiences can be educationally enriching.
Fines Called Draconian and Unfair
Nick Johnson from Dorset voiced strong support, adding that the justification for fines—that children miss valuable learning—is flawed. He noted that in the final weeks of term, teachers often resort to movies and games, with little curriculum learning taking place. "The argument that taking a child out of school a week before the end of term means they miss valuable learning is, frankly, laughable," he said.
Another reader, who chose to remain anonymous, described the policy as "appallingly unfair" and "unkind and small-minded," particularly for families with relatives overseas who face prohibitive travel costs during school holidays.
Personal Success Stories Challenge Fines
The anonymous reader shared a personal account: before the current regime, they took their daughter out of primary school annually for family visits and weddings. Despite a headteacher's warning that "if they miss a week of maths at seven, they never catch up," the daughter achieved 12 GCSEs with A*s, top marks in the International Baccalaureate, and a first-class university degree. The reader emphasized that this experience fostered intellectual curiosity and a healthy questioning of rules.
Retired Headteacher Agrees with Abolition
Barbara France, a retired headteacher from Arnside, Cumbria, expressed total agreement with Cosslett. "Many parents simply cannot afford to take a holiday when schools are closed, yet time away as a family is precious and above all can be educationally valuable and enriching," she said. "Never let schooling get in the way of your child's education."
Broader Debate on Term-Time Holidays
The letters respond to an article by Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett, published on 2 August, in which she argued that Labour should abolish fines for term-time holidays. The current policy, introduced in 2013, allows headteachers to issue fines of £60 per parent per child for unauthorized absences, rising to £120 if unpaid within 21 days. In 2023, the government tightened rules, eliminating the option to pay £60 per parent, making the fine £80 per parent per child.
Proponents of the fines argue they are necessary to maintain attendance and academic progress. However, critics highlight that the policy disproportionately affects low-income families and those with ties abroad. The debate continues as the Labour party considers potential reforms to the system.
