The Wednesday letters page responds to the Zelda Nintendo Direct, with readers offering a range of opinions on the Ocarina of Time remake. While many praised the improved visuals and quality-of-life features, others questioned the need for a faithful remake and the strategic release timing ahead of Grand Theft Auto 6.
Visuals and Faithfulness: A Mixed Reception
Reader Arteta26Legend expressed delight at the footage, noting that it appears to stay faithful to the original while adding a few extra elements that shouldn't detract from its core appeal. They also commented on the strategic timing of the release, referencing the proximity to another major game launch in the same month, which could keep fans of both franchises busy.
Bonfire Night was equally enthusiastic, describing the Direct as "worth the wait" and praising the remake as "a sympathetic remake, with just the right amount of extras." They highlighted the fully realised backdrops and bustling locals, ticking off familiar elements like Dodongo, Ghoma, and the Water Temple. They also expressed interest in the foil cover physical edition.
However, reader Simon voiced concerns about spoilers, admitting they skipped much of the Direct to experience key scenes firsthand. GameCentral advised caution, noting that the trailer features many key scenes from the game.
Debating the Remake Approach
Reader big boy bent offered a contrasting view, stating a preference for a 1:1 remake similar to the Star Fox treatment, updating graphics and music without adding new mechanics. They argued that if Nintendo intended to add a whole load of new mechanics, they should have made a brand-new Zelda game instead, as otherwise it isn't really Ocarina Of Time. They drew comparisons to the Resident Evil 4 remake, which they felt was the same game with improved graphics and updated bosses, and suggested that Ocarina Of Time still holds up today, unlike the original Resident Evil 1 which needed a remake.
Panda expressed disappointment, calling the remake a "missed opportunity" for a truly modern overhaul. They criticised the "faithful interpretation" approach, suggesting it might be a resource issue rather than a design choice. They lamented the lack of dungeon rejigging and seamless transitions between key areas, pointing out that even the Link's Awakening remake in 2019 had similar flaws. They also questioned the decision to show a full gameplay walkthrough in the Direct, as it spoiled puzzles that players already know well.
Quality-of-Life Improvements and Anticipation
Rob Taylor, Attorney at Bird Law, was particularly impressed by the quality-of-life features, citing the lack of loading screens when entering shops, as well as improved jump, dash, camera control, and time flow. They joked about buying the ocarina accessory and expressed concern about the cost of the 40th anniversary console. They also noted the release is 14 days before GTA 6, which they plan to play afterwards.
Nick The Greek shared hopes for Mario Kart World DLC rumours and expressed excitement for the Ocarina Of Time game, calling it "an all-time classic." They mentioned they would play Zelda first and wait for a 60fps mode for GTA 6.
Release Timing and Financial Concerns
matc7884, who had a packed gaming schedule, expressed concern about the financial burden of the holiday season, with only three pay days left before Christmas. They joked about hoping Nintendo wouldn't announce anything too unexpected in the Direct later that day, and asked for praise to be kept to a minimum for new releases to avoid feeling they're missing out. They also mentioned the upcoming Witcher 3 remaster, which they had a digital copy of on Switch.
Mark Matthews was super happy with how Ocarina Of Time looks, noting that the jumping loses a bit of the original feel but is acceptable if it brings new fans on board. The general consensus appears to be that while the remake is visually stunning and improves on the original in several ways, opinions are divided on whether it needed more substantial changes or should have remained a 1:1 update. The November 5 release date gives players a fortnight before Grand Theft Auto 6, which many see as a strategic move by Nintendo.
