Pluribus, the post-apocalyptic Apple TV Plus series from Breaking Bad creator Vince Gilligan, has been out for over six months but still hasn't achieved the mainstream recognition of other streaming hits. Despite a 99% Rotten Tomatoes critics' score based on 184 reviews, 18 Emmy nominations, and a Golden Globe and Critics Choice award for lead star Rhea Seehorn, the show struggles to generate the same buzz as Apple's Severance or other major Emmy contenders.
Awards and acclaim don't translate to cultural buzz
The series set a record for Apple TV Plus as its 'most watched show' with 360 million minutes viewed post-finale, surpassing Severance. Yet, outside of critical circles, Pluribus remains relatively unknown. When mentioned to friends and family, the response is often a glazed-over look or an apathetic 'Oh yeah, I've heard of that show, not watched it.' This contrasts sharply with Severance, which became a cultural phenomenon with widespread discussions about theories, love triangles, and existential themes.
The show's premise and Rhea Seehorn's performance
Pluribus follows Carol, a moody and cynical writer played by Rhea Seehorn, who is left unmoored when a virus sweeps the world, making everyone perpetually happy. Seehorn delivers one of the best performances on TV this year, portraying Carol's grief and panic with masterful depth. The dynamic between Carol and the virus-infected Zosia (Karolina Wydra) raises moral conundrums, but the show's slow-burn pacing has led to a 68% Rotten Tomatoes audience score, with some calling it 'boring.'
Why Pluribus deserves more attention
Vince Gilligan, speaking to Metro, revealed the show took nearly a decade to develop. 'When COVID hit, I remember thinking, oh, damn, everybody's going to think this is about COVID,' he said. 'But then AI comes along... it's up to the viewer to decide what it means.' The show's deliberate pace allows for deep character exploration, making Carol a compellingly unlikeable protagonist. Seehorn's Emmy nomination for Lead Actress in a Drama Series highlights her standout work, yet the show lacks the viral moments and fan edits that propel other series.
As the second season approaches, fans hope more viewers will discover Pluribus. The series is available to stream on Apple TV Plus now.
