Does Trump Now Own the US Supreme Court?
In a recent episode of the Guardian's Politics Weekly America podcast, Jonathan Freedland sat down with law professor and author Leah Litman to discuss the increasingly conservative-leaning US Supreme Court. The conversation delved into the court's decisions during the current legislative session, upcoming cases, and the growing argument that the institution has transformed from a legal body into a political one.
Conservative Shift Under Scrutiny
Litman, a professor at the University of Michigan Law School, highlighted how the court's recent rulings reflect a solid conservative majority, largely shaped by former President Donald Trump's three appointments. She noted that this term has seen decisions on abortion, gun rights, and environmental regulations that align closely with Republican priorities. Critics argue that the court is no longer an impartial arbiter of law but a political tool.
Key Cases and Controversies
The discussion covered several high-profile cases, including those involving executive power and religious freedom. Litman emphasized that the court's willingness to overturn long-standing precedents has raised concerns about its legitimacy. She pointed to the upcoming cases on affirmative action and voting rights as potential flashpoints that could further erode public trust.
A Political Institution?
Freedland and Litman explored why many now view the Supreme Court as a political institution. Litman argued that the confirmation process has become deeply partisan, with justices often ruling along ideological lines. She cited polls showing declining public confidence in the court, with many Americans believing it acts in the interests of the party that appointed them.
The podcast also touched on the impact of recent ethics scandals involving justices, which have fueled perceptions of bias. Litman called for reforms such as term limits and a binding code of conduct to restore faith in the judiciary.
Listeners can find the full episode of Politics Weekly America, along with the new Stateside with Kai and Carter podcast, on the Guardian's website.
