Viewers are finding themselves unable to stop watching a new Channel 5 stalker drama that has been described as 'ridiculously bad' yet 'weirdly intriguing.' The series, titled Number One Fan, follows daytime TV presenter Lucy Logan, played by soap legend Jill Halfpenny, as her seemingly perfect life unravels after being targeted by an unhinged stalker named Donna Hughes, portrayed by Sally Lindsay.
The four-part series, which also features Sharlene Whyte as manager Mel and Daniel Adegboyega as Shawn Logan, has drawn comparisons to the real-life ordeal of Holly Willoughby, who was the target of a kidnap plot by security guard Gavin Plumb. Plumb was sentenced to life in prison with a minimum term of 16 years for plotting to kidnap, rape, and murder the former This Morning presenter, an event that led Willoughby to quit the show and largely retreat from the public eye.
Mixed Reactions from Viewers
After the first episode aired on Monday, social media was abuzz with contrasting opinions. X user Lynn called the show 'terrible,' adding, 'I don't know if I can manage another episode… This is really, really bad.' Brooke labeled it 'far fetched,' while Chloe commented, 'What in the GCSE acting is this #numberonefan so bad it's good. The way this show is cringing me out so badly, but yet I can't stop watching it bc it's so weirdly intriguing this is ridiculously bad.'
Yvonne was similarly critical, stating: 'It's awful acting, the god-awful script, the pensive stares, the sets… not to mention the story. It's sooo TV daytime drama! Not one to put on the CV I think for anyone involved ? #numberonefan.'
Despite Criticism, Some Fans Are Hooked
However, not all responses were negative. Many viewers expressed their enjoyment and anticipation for the rest of the series. Michelle, describing Jill and Sally as 'two TV soap legends,' asked: 'Great episode of #NumberOneFan tonight! Now, do I watch the series live across the week, or do I binge?' Sophie declared: 'Just watched the first episode of Number One Fan on channel 5, Sally Lindsay is absolutely brilliant in it.' Kirsty added: 'Both actresses take a bow! Need more of the two working together,' while John said: 'I just knew this show was gonna be incredible.'
Controversy Surrounding Holly Willoughby Documentary
Last year, Willoughby reportedly criticized Channel 5's documentary about Plumb's fixation on her, originally titled The Plot to Kill Holly Willoughby. According to The Sun, Holly 'objected' to an earlier name, Stalking Holly Willoughby. A source claimed: 'Producers are ploughing ahead in making it regardless' due to expected high ratings. The insider added: 'She declined to be interviewed by producers about the ordeal, and her reps informed Channel 5 she wasn't technically stalked, so their title is incorrect. There is also concern that the events will be sensationally dramatized for effect. It's an awkward move, as it's not their story to tell.' The source also expressed fears that the production would bring back 'horrendous memories for entertainment purposes when she is just trying to move on with her life.'
Metro has contacted Holly Willoughby for comment.
