Sam Ryder's performance as Jesus in the revival of 'Jesus Christ Superstar' at the London Palladium has received mixed reviews, with critics noting his lack of acting experience as a significant drawback. The production, originally staged a decade ago at Regent's Park Open Air Theatre, features a broodingly sexy aesthetic and strong choreography, but Ryder's portrayal fails to match the intensity of his predecessor.
Ryder's Stage Debut Falls Short
Ryder, best known for finishing second at Eurovision, makes his stage debut in the lead role. While his musical background aligns with the rock opera's style, his acting is described as adequate but not commanding. The production includes moments where Jesus listens silently to Judas, played by Tyrone Huntley, and Ryder struggles to convey the inner turmoil that the role demands. Declan Bennett, who originated the role in 2016, brought brooding charisma, whereas Ryder appears like a 'mildly perturbed middle manager,' according to the review.
Strong Supporting Cast and Direction
Despite the lead's shortcomings, the production boasts strong elements. Director Timothy Sheader's cast, including Desdemona Cathabel as Mary Magdalene and Bob Harms as Caiaphas, deliver compelling performances. Drew McOnie's angular choreography and Tom Scutt's stark scaffold set enhance the apocalyptic atmosphere. The on-stage seating immerses the audience in the Judean crowd.
Gimmick of Rotating Herod
A notable feature is the rotating actor playing Herod, with Jesse Tyler Ferguson performing during the reviewed show. Upcoming performers include Boy George and Richard Armitage. However, the review notes this is a minor gimmick for a cameo role.
Production Context and Comparison
The revival slots into the 'Sexy Lloyd Webber' era under Jamie Lloyd, following last year's 'Evita' starring Rachel Zegler. The review contrasts Ryder's performance unfavorably with Zegler's, stating that while she was 'astonishing,' Ryder is merely a pop star, not a superstar. The musical itself remains praised for its innovative score and lyrics by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice.
'Jesus Christ Superstar' runs at the London Palladium until September 5, 2026, before moving to Theatre Royal Drury Lane from October 16, 2026, to January 9, 2027.
